0  

    BAILII [Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback]

    European Court of Human Rights
    You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> European Court of Human Rights >> MALMBERG AND OTHER APPLICATIONS v. RUSSIA - 23045/05 (Communicated Case) [2012] ECHR 1239 (03 July 2012)
    URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2012/1239.html
    Cite as: [2012] ECHR 1239

    [New search] [Contents list] [Printable RTF version] [Help]

    FIRST SECTION

    Application no. 23045/05
    Mariya Gennadyevna MALMBERG against Russia
    and 7 other applications
    (see list appended)

    STATEMENT OF FACTS

    THE FACTS

    The applicants are Russian nationals.

    The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.

    The applicants were parties to civil proceedings. Only operative parts of judgments in their cases (see table appended) were read out by courts. The reasoned judgments were prepared after the hearings.

    COMPLAINTS


    1.  The applicants complain that the judgments in their civil cases were not pronounced publicly as required by Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.


    2.  They also lodge other complaints under the Convention.

    QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES


    1.  Were the judgments in the present cases (see table appended) of the first-instance and the appeal courts pronounced publicly, as required by Article 6 § 1 of the Convention? In particular, was the reading out of the judgments of the first-instance and the appeal courts at the hearings limited to the operative part (???????????? ?????), and, if so, were the reasoned judgments, which were prepared after the hearings, made public by any other means (see Ryakib Biryukov v. Russia, no. 14810/02, ECHR 2008)?

     


    2.  When were the reasoned judgments of the first-instance and the appeal courts in their final forms (?????????????? ??????? ????, ??????? ???? ? ????????????? ?????) prepared?

     

    The Government are requested to submit the court records of the hearings (????????? ???????? ?????????) before the first-instance and the appeal courts, and the operative parts (???????????? ?????) of the judgments, unless they were submitted by the applicants. The Government are also requested to submit statements of the applicants’ appeals against the first-instance courts’ judgments in applications nos. 23045/05, 39543/08, 48789/09 and 31011/10.

     

     


    APPENDIX

     

    No

    Application

    no.

    Lodged on

    Applicant’s name

    date of birth

    place of residence

    Judgments which were not allegedly pronounced publicly

    1.                     

    23045/05

    03/05/2005

    Mariya Gennadyevna MALMBERG

    06/10/1957

    St Petersburg 

     

    St Petersburg City Court’s judgment of 21 December 2004 (the City Court partially quashed Vasileostrovskiy District Court’s judgment of 17 March 2004 and took a new decision on the merits). Contractual dispute between private individuals.

     

    2.                     

    39543/08

    17/06/2008

    Yevgeniya Yekimovna SHUBINA

    01/01/1960

    Belgorod 

     

    Belgorodskiy District Court’s judgment of 11 March 2008 and Belgorod Regional Court’s judgment of 22 April 2008 (the appeal court took a new decision on the merits). Consumer dispute.

     

    3.                     

    21236/09

    02/04/2009

    Mikhaydar Ayseyevich TAZIKOV

    23/05/1957

    Ulyanovsk 

     

    Ulyanovsk Leninskiy District Court’s judgment of 13 October 2008 and Ulyanovsk Regional Court’s judgment of 25 November 2008 (the District Court’s judgment was upheld on appeal). Dispute between private individuals concerning debt recovery.

     

    4.                     

    48789/09

    21/08/2009

    Sergey Nikolayevich VOROBYEV

    10/11/1965

    Saransk 

     

    Saransk Oktyabrskiy District Court’s judgment of 26 December 2008 and Mordoviya Republic Supreme Court’s judgment of 10 March 2009. Insurance dispute concerning a traffic accident.

     

    5.                     

    58611/09

    17/10/2009

    Svetlana Yuryevna SAUTCHENKOVA

    27/12/1972

    Krasnodar 

     

    Krasnodar Pervomayskiy District Court’s judgment of 18 August 2009 (upheld by Krasnodar Regional Court’s judgment of 29 September 2009). Dispute with a private bank concerning validity of a collateral agreement.

     

    6.                     

    17759/10

    17/02/2010

    Olga Ivanovna SHEVCHENOK

    19/02/1958

    Tyumen 

     

    Tavdinskiy District Court’s judgment of 26 June 2009 (upheld by Sverdlovsk Regional Court’s judgment of 18 August 2009). Land dispute with a local authority.

     

    7.                     

    31011/10

    31/03/2010

    Svetlana Yuryevna SAUTCHENKOVA

    27/12/1972

    Krasnodar 

     

    Krasnodar Prikubanskiy District Court’s judgment of 18 December 2009 (upheld by Krasnodar Regional Court’s judgment of 25 February 2010). Dispute with a private bank concerning the applicant’s liability as a guarantor under a bank loan agreement.

     

    8.                     

    48402/10

    27/07/2010

    Marina Fedorovna SURKOVA

    06/06/1946

    Moscow 

     

    Basmanniy District Court’s judgment of 30 October 2009 and Moscow City Court’s judgment of 28 January 2010 (the District Court’s judgment was upheld on appeal). Labour dispute concerning Federal Service of State Statistics’ refusal of employment.

     

BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII
URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2012/1239.html