BAILII [Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback]

Scottish Court of Session Decisions


You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> Scottish Court of Session Decisions >> Sandeman v Shepherd [1835] CA 13_1037 (4 July 1835)
URL: http://www.bailii.org/scot/cases/ScotCS/1835/013SS1037.html
Cite as: [1835] CA 13_1037

[New search] [Help]


SCOTTISH_Shaw_Court_of_Session

Page: 1037

Sandeman

v.

Shepherd
No. 318.

Court of Session

1st Division

July 4 1835

Lord Mackenzie

Edward Sandeman,     Pursuer. Alexander Shepherd and John Macandrew,     Defenders.— Rutherfurd. William Low,     Compearer— Russell.

Subject_Expenses—Bankruptcy.—

The party to a depending process became bankrupt, and intimation was made to his trustee, who proposed to sist himself under the condition of not being liable for the expenses incurred prior to sequestration—Held, 1. That the trustee must either sist himself unconditionally or not at all; and, 2, That, after being sisted, it was still open to him to plead that he was not liable for the prior expenses, and the Court would then decide whether such plea was well founded.

An action at the instance of Sandeman against Shepherd and Macandrew had proceeded so far that the record was closed, and a judgment was pronounced by the Lord Ordinary, against which Sandeman reclaimed. His estates were then sequestrated, and intimation being made to William Low, his trustee, Low proposed to sist himself under the condition of being liable in any event only for such expenses as were incurred subsequently to the sequestration. The defenders objected to this, and contended that he must either sist himself unconditionally or not at all.

Lord Mackenzie.—It is open to the trustee, after having sisted himself, to plead that he has not thereby incurred liability for the expenses prior to the sequestration, and when he does so the Court will decide whether the plea be well founded. But in the mean time, if he is to sist himself at all, he must do it without any qualification of his liability for expenses.

The other judges concurred, and farther time was allowed to Low to decide whether he should sist himself or not.

Solicitors: J. Bennett, W.S.— ÆNeas Macbean, W.S,—Agents.

SS 13 SS 1037 1835


BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII
URL: http://www.bailii.org/scot/cases/ScotCS/1835/013SS1037.html